Top 5 Website Mistakes That Make You Look Amateur (Even If You’re Not)
Certain design and content missteps can unintentionally make your business appear less polished even if you’re an expert in your field. The good news? These are usually quick to identify and even easier to fix once you know what to look for. Let’s explore five common website mistakes that can unintentionally undermine your credibility, and what you can do to elevate your site and stand out with confidence.
Cluttered or Confusing Design
An overly busy website filled with different fonts, clashing colors, popups, and competing calls to action can leave your visitors feeling overwhelmed. Instead of being guided toward the information they’re looking for, they’re met with digital chaos, and they’ll likely leave before they find what they need. A confusing design doesn’t just affect user experience, it also suggests a lack of professionalism and strategy behind the brand.
Brand Studio Creative Pro Fix:
Simplicity is your best friend. Stick to a clean, intentional layout that prioritizes white space and hierarchy. Use no more than 2-3 brand fonts and a cohesive color palette to create a calm, consistent visual experience. Every page should guide the user with one clear goal; whether that’s to book a call, download a freebie, or learn more about your services. Keep navigation intuitive, and resist the urge to include everything in one place. When in doubt, declutter.
Lack of Clear Messaging
If your homepage doesn’t immediately communicate who you are, what you offer, and why it matters, you’re missing the mark. Most visitors will decide on your business within seconds, and if they don’t understand the value you provide, or feel like it’s not for them, they’ll move on. Vague, clever, or overly technical language can alienate the very people you’re trying to reach.
Brand Studio Creative Pro Fix:
Lead with clarity. Your hero section (the top part of your homepage) should instantly answer the questions: Who do you help? What do you help them achieve? Why does it matter? Use language that speaks directly to your ideal client’s needs and pain points. Keep it conversational but confident. A powerful headline, a short supporting sentence, and a clear call to action can dramatically improve how quickly your audience connects with your brand.
DIY Logos and Inconsistent Branding
While it’s tempting to DIY your logo or mix and match fonts and colors based on what looks good at the moment, this approach often results in visual inconsistency. A logo that looks unpolished, blurry images or pages that use different tones and styles can instantly make your brand feel less credible. People subconsciously equate brand consistency with reliability.
Brand Studio Creative Pro Fix:
Invest in branding by hiring a designer or, at minimum, creating a simple style guide you can stick to. This includes a clear logo, a color palette with hex codes, 2-3 brand fonts, and guidelines for photography and tone of voice. Consistent branding builds trust, boosts recognition, and signals that you take your business seriously. Even a minimalist but consistent visual identity can make a powerful impression.
Slow Load Times and Broken Links
No one has the patience for a website that takes forever to load. In fact, most users wil abandon a page if it doesn’t load within three seconds. Broken links, 404 errors, or glitchy pages can damage your brand’s reputation and make your site feel outdated or neglected. And from an SEO standpoint, these issues can tank your ranking and reduce visibility.
Brand Studio Creative Pro Fix:
Start by running a speed and performance audit using tools like Google PageSpeed Insights or GTmetrix. Optimize large images by compressing them, removing unnecessary plugins or outdated scripts, and ensuring your hosting platform supports fast load speeds. Regularly test your links and update any redirects to avoid broken paths. Think of website maintenance like self-care; it’s not glamorous, but it makes all the difference.
No Clear Way to Contact You
You’ve sparked interest and built trust, don’t lose momentum with missing or hard-to-find contact information. If a visitor has to dig through multiple pages or scroll endlessly just to get in touch, they’ll likely give up and move on. This simple mistake can quietly cost you valuable leads and credibility. Making your contact information clear and accessible signals that you’re approachable, responsive, and ready to do business.
Brand Studio Creative Pro Fix:
Make your contact details highly visible and accessible across your website. Include a “Contact” tab in your main navigation bar, and add links or forms in your footer for easy access. If you book discovery calls, include prominent buttons that say “Book a Call” or “Let’s Talk”. Bonus tip: Make your calls to action friendly and welcoming. A simple “Have questions? Let’s chat!” can feel more inviting than “Submit your inquiry”.
If you’re ready to polish up your site and create a seamless experience that truly reflects the quality of your work, now’s the perfect time. Do a quick website audit, make the tweaks, and if you need expert guidance, we are always just a message away!
Book a FREE 1:1 Website Audit Call and let us guide you through this incredible journey. Together, we can make magic happen!
XOXO, Katie
Are you struggling with your brand?
Knowing where to start is hard, but we are here to make this process streamlined and effortless. We care about the success of your company and ensure that your brand represents YOU and your vision. Our team is lead by a master’s in brand strategy and communications CEO working hard so you can expect that your business will be visually consistent both digitally and in print.
Subscribe to the Newsletter
Join my mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from me.
You have Successfully Subscribed!